You’ve Been Voted Off The Island…

Eventually, we sit down GC and tell him the news. Boy, that was awkward! And it goes down in a way where all 4 of us are in the room at the same time. So there was no real escape for anyone.

PJ and AD break the news as gently as they can but the whole time, I’m being quiet and to myself, trying to not get involved. While it’s all happening, everyone is taking occasional glances at me, as if expecting me to say something. I’m staring into middle space and biting my nails at this point! 😯

But here’s why this thing was so stressful for me: I had no problems with any of my roommates! So this was really an issue between the other three. I wanted to be Switzerland! But unfortunately, that’s not how things played out for me. My problem was that I had to take a side in this scenario. Why? Well, there are two ways this could have played out for me:

  1. I take one of the sides (which would be PJ’s side) and have the other side dislike me.
  2. I take no sides and have them both question my integrity.

I originally wanted to go with option #2 but the longer I thought about it, the more I thought that if I did it would not work out in my favor in the long run. If I had decided to not say a word and not get involved, PJ and AD would look at me very differently. They would wonder if I would stand up with them in the future. GC would wonder why I didn’t make a remark, leaving me to look unconcerned with his dilemma. That’s a no-go for me on both sides! 😦

What also made me not go with option #2 is the things that PJ and AD told me before this conversation happened. PJ had told me that he wanted (expected really) for me to take his side. AD told me that if I stood up with them, it makes their argument stronger and it doesn’t make it look like the two of them are attacking GC. So of course, all of this is swirling and bouncing around inside my head as this conversation is taking place with GC.

So before it was too late, I went with option #1 . I took PJ and AD’s side and just agreed with them. Now I spun it where I sorta acted as a middleman but still stood on the “attacking” side. I really didn’t want to jeopardize the bond I had formed with two guys I’d be continuing to live with after GC moved out. That would be just TOO awkward for me. Plus, if I was going to take a side, let it be the one where I have the most support.

To be frank, no one left that conversation feeling good. Especially me and GC. I was forced to do something I really didn’t want to do and GC had been abandoned. It just sucked for lack of better words. GC stopped talking with us after that.

What kills me though, is that days after the conversation happened, PJ and AD went back to normal as if nothing ever happened! Like, maybe I’m just super sensitive, but I couldn’t understand how they could just pretend like GC wasn’t clearly heartbroken every time they saw him. I tried to reach out to GC but he didn’t really want to talk. All I could get was a mere “Hi.”

Then, eventually, the semester ended and were all went home to our hometowns for the holidays. There was A LOT that happened between us leaving and us coming back for the Spring semester. But basically, it boiled down to me trying to console GC and really squash the remaining confusion between everyone. Luckily, it was successful.

When we all came back, something strange happened. It was like the conversation never occurred. Everyone (even GC) was getting along and happy and, well, compatible again! And now, I’m left in a state of confusion, and remorse for what is to come. It only makes me wonder what could’ve been if we had worked it out more before it came to what it did.

Personally, I’m going to miss GC. He might have done some things that were annoying from time to time but I will really miss having him around all the time. I don’t know about PJ and AD, but I will miss him. It’s even more disheartening for me now because GC and I are actually getting closer than we were before the conversation happened. So when he leaves, it will hurt more than it originally would have.

Yeah, these moments happen in life. Sometimes you gotta make a tough choice. And while I look forward to the new roommate (who I like just as much as AD and PJ), it doesn’t make GC’s leave any less difficult to deal with.


But there you have it guys. Quite a long story for you, I know. But I just wanted to come and get that one off of my chest. I do hope that maybe you got something out of that. Maybe you could learn from my experience. But whatever the case, thank you for reading. 🙂

Well, until next time, cheers.

Have you had to make a tough choice before? What would you have done if you were me? Leave all of your thoughts below!



13 thoughts on “You’ve Been Voted Off The Island…

  1. I guess it was for the best, there wouldn’t be an harmony if roommates are at odds.It is one of things I hate with living with roomies.If there is a problem you’ll be the last to know. Don’t despair GC will be all right just make sure the other two don’t turn on you.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah. GC will be fine alright. And I don’t think the others will turn on me. Especially since they know I know particular information about their lives. It wouldn’t be in their favor to turn on me. I can switch from being sweet to sour real quick. But I hope it doesn’t come to that.
      Thanks for stopping by George! 🙂 Love hearing your thoughts.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I think you did the right thing, you had no qualms one way or the other therefore why jump in. Also giving GC plenty of time to find another place was the right thing to do. I’m sensing you may not feel totally comfortable with asking GC to move out since you are writing about it. If that is the case, what is it that’s bothering you, do you feel you were unfair to GC by asking him to move out? Whatever the reason is, just be true to yourself about it and if you feel it necessary to say something to GC that would make you feel better than do so. In a few years from now this won’t be important as long as you handled GC with respect, all is well! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes. All is well actually. GC and I yalked privately after this happening. I told him my full thoughts and he understood that I really never wanted to get involved. So we are on very good terms, now more than before. That’s why I’m gonna miss having him in the house.
      Thank you for reading Deb! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Awww … poor GC, to be voted out of the casa. I think what matters is how the message was delivered. But yes my initial reaction would be to exclude myself from the situation 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I’m just like you, a peacemaker — don’t involve me in any conflict, please. Someone has to be doing me oh so wrong before I feel the need to say something to them. I prefer to give things time to work themselves out. However… I’m no doormat either.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. You always take me back to my college days….oh so long ago. But guess what, things were like that then and with me as with you. Strange, but we were girls. And we only had three. But never the less, it was uncomfortable and sad. It seemed so much of my life I was the one in the middle and played the role of peace maker a lot. I never worried about my integrity but now I wonder if others wondered about it. I guess all you can do is just do the best you can at the time and make the best possible decision. But always try to end up shaking everyone’s hands. For us girls, we hugged….

    Liked by 1 person

Interject Your Thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s